Pensioner's injuries were "worst" Detective had ever seen

A senior detective today told a court the injuries suffered by a 67-year-old mechanic bludgeoned to death in his home were the worst he had ever seen.

Friday, 25th January 2019, 5:18 pm
Updated Friday, 25th January 2019, 5:25 pm
Brian McKandie

Brian McKandie was brutally beaten to death at his home in Badenscoth, near Rothienorman, on March 11 2016.

Steven Sidebottom denies murdering and robbing the 67-year-old mechanic.

Today Detective Inspector Gary Winter, of Police Scotland's Major Investigation Team, told the jury police had interviewed over 1,800 people during door to door enquiries in the weeks and scoured CCTV footage obtained from properties across a 152 square mile area.

The 13th day of the trial also heard that Mr McKandie had left an estate of over £800,000 following his death comprising of bank accounts, investments, his property and £200,000 of cash stuffed in boxes around his home.

The court was also shown footage from a BBC Crimewatch programme in which an appeal was launched for information some six months after the killing.

During it a senior detective urges anyone who had seen two men in a burgundy car at Mr McKandie's home the day of his death to come forward.

But DI Winter - who was the deputy senior investigating officer in the probe - told the court that he had now ruled out that car having been at the scene on the day.

He said: "That weekend [after the murder investigation was launched] a witness came forward saying there were two people there around 5pm.

"We took that in good faith that the witness was accurate and had no reason to disbelieve them.

"We put that out but by putting it out that quickly we don't have he time to check the credibility of that. That resulted in other witnesses coming forward.

"There is no physical evidence to support those people and that vehicle having been there that day."

Turning to the brutality of the attack on Mr McKandie, advocate depute Iain McSporran QC said: "I take it I would not be wrong that the level of violence was extreme?"

DI Winter said: "I have never ever seen injuries like that."

Defence counsel Iain Duguid QC asked DI Winter if he was aware of a witness describing men arguing with Mr McKandie outside his home on the evening he died.

He added: "Did anyone describe in a statement making a finger gesture that suggested a gun type activity?"

DI Winter said: "Not that I'm aware of."

Sidebottom, 25, of Rothienorman, denies a single charge of murder.

It is alleged that on March 11 2016 at Fairview Cottages, Badenscoth, Rothienorman, he murdered Brian McKandie and robbed him of a sum of money.

Sidebottom denies repeatedly striking Mr McKandie with an unidentified implement or implements.

He has lodged special defences of alibi and incrimination.

The trial, before judge Lord Uist and a jury of five men and ten women, continues